Cowboys Draft Report Card: Grading The Dallas Picks!

Hey Cowboys Nation! The 2024 NFL Draft is in the books, and it's time to break down how the Dallas Cowboys did. Did Jerry and the boys nail it, or did they whiff? Let's dive into the Dallas Cowboys Draft Report Card and see how each pick stacks up. We'll be looking at everything from positional needs to value and overall impact. Grab your star and let's get started, because it’s time to grade the Cowboys' newest additions!

Round 1: Offensive Tackle - Tyler Guyton, Oklahoma (Pick 29)

Alright, guys, let's kick things off with the big fella: Tyler Guyton. The Cowboys snagged this offensive tackle from Oklahoma with their first-round pick. This pick addressed a huge need, as the offensive line needed some serious reinforcements. The Cowboys clearly recognized the need to protect Dak Prescott and open up running lanes for the offense. Guyton is a project, sure, but he possesses the physical tools to become a dominant force. He's got the size, athleticism, and the raw power that offensive line coaches dream of. He needs some refinement in his technique, especially with his hands and footwork, but the potential is undeniable. This is a smart pick for the Cowboys, addressing a key position with a player who has a high ceiling. This pick is all about the future, with the expectation that Guyton will develop into a long-term starter at either tackle spot. The Cowboys will likely be patient with his development, and he may not start immediately. Guyton, however, could be a key player for many years to come, solidifying the offensive line. The selection of Tyler Guyton also indicated the Cowboys’ understanding of the current NFL trends and their attempt to stay competitive. Guyton’s size and agility will be valuable assets in today's game. Dallas is aiming to ensure that they stay competitive in the NFC. If his development progresses as expected, he could be a cornerstone of the Cowboys' offensive line for years to come. Ultimately, this pick is a calculated risk with a potentially massive reward.

Grade: B+

Round 2: Defensive End - Marshawn Kneeland, Western Michigan (Pick 56)

In the second round, the Cowboys opted to bolster their pass rush with Marshawn Kneeland, a defensive end out of Western Michigan. This was another smart move, as the Cowboys' defensive line could use some added depth and talent. Kneeland brings a combination of size, power, and surprising athleticism. He's a disruptive force who can get after the quarterback and also contribute against the run. He's got a relentless motor and a knack for finding the ball. Kneeland might not be a household name, but he was a productive player in college and should be able to make an immediate impact as a rotational player. The second-round pick of Marshawn Kneeland is a strategic move to boost the Cowboys' defensive front. His power and relentless play style perfectly align with the Cowboys' defensive scheme, which requires consistent pressure on the quarterback. The Cowboys understand that success in the NFL hinges on having a strong defensive line that can disrupt the opposing offense. Kneeland will provide some serious competition for playing time and should thrive in a rotational role. The Cowboys' coaching staff will likely work on refining his technique. Kneeland has all the tools to develop into a key contributor for the team. This pick is about adding a high-motor player who can consistently generate pressure and make plays in the backfield. If Kneeland can develop the required technique and skills, he can become a key player on the defensive line. The Cowboys are building their defense with depth and versatility, and Kneeland is a great fit. His dedication and passion for the game are evident, and his presence will certainly energize the entire defensive unit.

Grade: A-

Round 3: Offensive Line - Cooper Beebe, Kansas State (Pick 73)

Moving into the third round, the Cowboys continued their effort to build a strong offensive line by selecting Cooper Beebe, an offensive lineman from Kansas State. Beebe is a versatile player who has experience at both guard and tackle, making him a valuable addition to the roster. His ability to play multiple positions gives the coaching staff some flexibility and ensures he can see action in several spots. Beebe is known for his strength, technique, and football IQ. He's a tough, reliable player who should be able to contribute right away. This pick is another example of the Cowboys focusing on building a foundation in the trenches. The selection of Cooper Beebe in the third round shows the team’s continued dedication to solidifying their offensive line. The ability to play multiple positions makes him an ideal pick, offering the team strategic flexibility. His strength, technique, and high football IQ are perfect for the Cowboys' scheme. Beebe will bring a level of stability and versatility to the offensive line. His potential to contribute to the line immediately is a massive advantage. Beebe’s impact will be felt sooner than later, especially if injuries plague the starting unit. Beebe’s arrival means that the Cowboys are making sure the offensive line is ready for any challenge. He will provide depth and competition at multiple positions. Beebe’s presence will significantly boost the team’s prospects for success. The Cowboys' offensive line will benefit greatly from Beebe’s experience and versatility. He is a fantastic addition to the team.

Grade: A

Round 5: Cornerback - Caelen Carson, Wake Forest (Pick 174)

In the fifth round, the Cowboys addressed their secondary by selecting Caelen Carson, a cornerback from Wake Forest. Carson brings good size and athleticism to the table. He is an aggressive corner who likes to challenge receivers at the line of scrimmage. He has shown flashes of potential, and with good coaching, he could develop into a reliable player. This pick is about adding depth to the cornerback position and hoping to find a hidden gem. Carson is a player who could contribute on special teams. The choice of Caelen Carson, a cornerback from Wake Forest, in the fifth round showcases the Cowboys' efforts to strengthen their secondary. Carson’s size and athleticism offer the team a promising new addition. His aggressive style and willingness to challenge receivers at the line of scrimmage make him a solid prospect. Carson’s performance in the upcoming seasons will have a huge impact on the team. He'll get a chance to show what he's made of. This pick is a gamble, but it's one worth taking. Carson could have an impact on special teams as well. The Cowboys' coaching staff will want to hone his skills and help him develop. Overall, it's a great addition that has the potential to pay off.

Grade: B

Round 6: Linebacker - Nathan Thomas, Louisiana (Pick 216)

With their final pick, the Cowboys selected linebacker Nathan Thomas from Louisiana. This pick adds depth to a position where the Cowboys could use some more talent. Thomas is an athletic linebacker who has shown a knack for making plays. He's a developmental player who will need some time to learn the ropes. The Cowboys hope they can turn him into a valuable contributor. The selection of Nathan Thomas in the sixth round allows the Cowboys to add depth to their linebacker corps. The athleticism and playmaking ability of Thomas will be valuable. This pick is a project, and the team will need time to help him to refine his skills. Thomas could carve out a role on special teams. It's a low-risk, high-reward pick that could pay off if Thomas develops well. The Cowboys hope to find a gem late in the draft. It is important to remember that most sixth-round picks are projects. The Cowboys see potential in Nathan Thomas and they hope it will pay off.

Grade: C+

Overall Draft Grade

So, what's the overall takeaway from the Cowboys' draft class? The Cowboys focused on their key needs, particularly the offensive line and defensive line, which were top priorities. They added some players with high potential who could become long-term contributors. The draft class has a solid foundation with potential stars, and this draft class reflects a good strategy. They made smart selections and also targeted areas where they needed the most help. The Dallas Cowboys’ draft strategy centered on bolstering key positions, particularly the offensive and defensive lines, which were prioritized throughout the selections. The front office aimed to secure immediate depth and to scout long-term starters. The Cowboys selected players with the potential to develop and make a significant impact on the team. The Cowboys' drafting approach showcased a plan designed to ensure that the team is ready for long-term success. The Cowboys' selections emphasize building a strong foundation and finding players who fit their team's culture. This draft will contribute to the Cowboys’ competitiveness in the NFC. Overall, this draft class shows that the Cowboys are focused on building a winning team.

Overall Grade: B+

What do you guys think? Let me know your thoughts in the comments! Did the Cowboys get it right, or did they miss the mark? Let's discuss!